An inquest jury has found that shortcomings in a police search at Royal Stoke University Hospital probably contributed to the death of 28-year-old Dwayne Nicklin, who was later found in a car park lift.

This article is based on reporting from the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS), a BBC funded initiative set up to strengthen reporting on local democratic issues. The Staffordshire Signal has taken part in the scheme since September 2026, which means we're able to draw on a selection of LDRS stories alongside our own.
What’s new: An inquest jury has concluded that shortcomings in a police search probably contributed to the death of Dwayne Nicklin in December 2023.
Why it matters: Jurors identified poor communication between officers, reliance on uncorroborated CCTV footage and a failure to search the lift where Dwayne was later found.
Between the lines: The jury concluded that Dwayne's actions were deliberate but could not determine whether he intended to take his own life.
An inquest jury has concluded there were shortcomings in the police search for a dad of two who was later found dead in a hospital car park lift.
Dwayne Nicklin was just 28 when he died from hanging at Royal Stoke University Hospital in December 2023 – but the inquest jury were unable to determine on Tuesday (November 17) whether he had intended to take his own life.
The jury did consider however that there was poor communication between officers involved in the search for Dwayne on the hospital site in the early hours of December 28, as well as an over-reliance on uncorroborated CCTV footage. They concluded the shortcomings “probably contributed more than minimally to the death”, he was still alive when two officers conducted a search of the car park and that if a more thorough search had been conducted it was “likely more than not police would have been able to find Mr Nicklin and been able to intervene”, by using powers under the Mental Health Act to take him to a place of safety.
Dwayne, from Blurton, had previously been diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder and emotional unstable personality disorder and had a history of self-harm and suicidal thoughts. He had been prescribed medication and was under the care of the Sutherland Centre, which provides mental health services in Dresden, during 2023.
At the start of that year he had lost his job and during 2023 he also faced a relationship breakdown and homelessness. On December 5 mental health services were contacted by one of Dwayne’s friends who was concerned about a self-harm image he had posted on Facebook.
Two days later he attended the crisis care centre at Harplands Hospital and wanted to be admitted. Dwayne was told during an assessment admission was unlikely, but offered support in seeking emergency accommodation and a taxi to a friend’s house, but left the centre of his own accord in the early hours of December 8.
In the early hours of December 28 Dwayne video called his former partner, who he had spent around a week with over the festive period before leaving her address on Christmas Day. She called 999 shortly after 1am on December 28, after he said he was by a car park near Harplands Hospital, and the inquest heard he looked as if he was attempting to hang himself.
Police were dispatched to Harplands Hospital within two minutes of the 999 call, with the first pair of officers arriving at 1.21am. They initially searched the grounds of the mental health hospital, but were unable to locate Dwayne there.
They moved on to nearby Royal Stoke University Hospital, where the search covered car parks and buildings. Dwayne called his former partner again before 2am, stating he was in a lift at the hospital, and it was believed he may have been in the hospital’s Lyme Building – an area he had previously frequented during his downtime at a previous hospital security job.
Police were assisted by hospital security staff in their search, who checked their CCTV cameras in a bid to locate Dwayne, and it was believed he was sighted in the Lyme Building some time before 3am. Calls were also made to his phone, which rang out but was not answered before going to voicemail.
Two officers conducted a search of the multi storey car park – the only multi storey car park in operation and accessible to the public at the hospital site at the time – at around 1.30am, following their arrival at the scene. They had heard he may be in a lift in a car park close to Harplands Hospital, but they did not know where the lift was located prior to their arrival.
The pair searched different areas of the car park, including stairwells. But the inquest heard that neither of the officers’ searches included the lift – and there were no CCTV cameras covering the lift.
Dwayne was found in the lift at around 8am by a hospital staff member arriving for work. The jury concluded that Dwayne’s hanging “was a deliberate act by the deceased”, but did not ascertain whether or not he intended to take his own life.
Daniel Howe, Area Coroner for Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent, said to Dwayne’s family: “I express my condolences. I’m sorry for the circumstances that bring you before the court.”
Written by Kerry Ashdown, Local Democracy Reporter.
Why the Signal exists
Real news takes time. Thanks for taking yours.
You've just read a story that took time to get right. No clickbait, no racing to be first, no ads chasing you down the page.
I started The Staffordshire Signal because I got fed up of local news that chased clicks instead of stories. We're independent, not-for-profit, IMPRESS-regulated and owned right here, so we answer to nobody but you.
The honest bit: local news only survives if local people choose it. If we don't, it goes.
Jenna GoodwinFounder and Editor, The Staffordshire Signal
Love what we do?
Buy us an oatcake! Cheese and bacon, if you're feeling generous. Every tip goes straight into local reporting.
Buy us an oatcakeMiss a proper paper?
Staffordshire's only regional printed magazine, full of stories worth sitting down with, delivered to your door.
Get it deliveredFollow on WhatsApp
Our stories, dropped straight into your phone. No group chat chaos, we promise.
Join the channelFind something good to do this week
Markets, gigs, history talks and family days out across Staffordshire. Running an event? Add it to our guide and let the county know.
Run a Staffordshire business?
Our readers keep the Signal going, and the businesses who advertise with us help keep it free for everyone. Reach people who read to the end, across our magazine, Signal Weekly, Signal TV and website.
Explore the heart of our county Use the interactive map above to discover local landmarks, heritage sites, and community-vetted spots. Every interaction helps support The Staffordshire Signal’s mission to keep local news free and independent.


Uttoxeter Restaurant Lowe’s to Deliver 250 Free Christmas Dinners to Families in Need
NHS Urges Staffordshire Parents to Use Antibiotics Wisely as Prescribing Rates Exceed Target
Tunstall Property Owner Ordered to Pay £5,598 Over Historic Building's Disrepair
Hans Christian Andersen’s Christmas classic reimagined at Leek Library
JCB Launches Fifth Christmas Toy Appeal to Help Local Children